Strawberry Letter

When Role Playing Goes Too Far

Dear Steve and Shirley, I am in my early twenties and I’m dating a guy that I’ve known this since high school. He was my high school crush and I always dreamed of being his girl. He had a longtime girlfriend and they broke up last year, so I made the first move to see if he was interested. He was, and we’ve been dating for five months now. He is a good boyfriend and the sex was as good as I thought it would be. Everything about him was pretty normal until recently, when I noticed he had a couple of furry animal costumes in his closet. We were lying in his bed, talking, and I noticed them so I jokingly asked if they were some old Halloween costumes………….

Learn more about your ad-choices at

See for privacy information.